|
| |
|
Future of microfinance in Pakistan |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
Recent floods in Pakistan have further plunged the already reeling economy. The estimation of the total damage will take some time but the need to microfinance the victims are dire as the failure in this sector can create a famine in not too distant a future.
The government is already cash-strapped and avoided default the last year with the help of IMF. Another dilemma is the trust deficit due to which the enough aid is not coming and the donors are relying upon the non-governmental bodies.
The real challenge is that of rehabilitating the destroyed businesses of the flood victims as through this process we can even fight the hunger and disease by reestablishing their productivity.
Pakistan is said to be a predominantly an agricultural economy and it was this sector that has been severely damaged. Through microfinance and SMEs, this damage can effectively be dealt with in a matter next 5 to 10 years. Millions of acres of agri land has presently been under flood waters. And the only redeeming feature is the fertility that the flood will leave behind.
Here comes the role of the microfinance and SME but with a difference as the damaged has been caused by various internal and external causes. No doubt this is the time when the investments are taking a very interesting twist from the conventional to Islamic and from microfinance to small medium enterprise as well. Although the various conventional MFIs are shifting their mode of financing also, but they could not have positive results and the mission rift issue is another tragic story, told by these MFIs.
As I ever admitted that only the microfinance could reduce the miseries of the vulnerable. However, the sector has to come with a new enthusiasm and an innovative paradigm.
As the current scenario of Pakistan demands a well planned agriculture based microfinance or SME financing to ensure the rehabilitation of the flood victim rural community of Pakistan.
According to a study conducted by Farz Foundation, 50% population in rural areas of Pakistan earns livelihood from agriculture and 50% from other sources. The people involve in agribusinesses also do live stock as another source of income. While the other 50% population do the businesses like grocery shops, and transport, embroidery along with the labor on daily wages.
Instead of group methodology or village banking etc, the product of entrepreneur or SME village through the vehicle of Farz Methodology could have a far wider scope as the earlier methods could not reach out to a considerable number of people. That is the only way to have the long awaited trickle down effect so that it could lend economic stability at a macro level as well through “Twist Up Economy”( Twist up theory emerges as a rejoinder to trickle down theory. It is a course with the notion that the sustained micro and small businesses assure the sustainability of the macro economics. It increases the numbers of consumers and their capability to buy. It also strengthens the markets and supports rich persons to expand their businesses. The Farz Methodology implements Twist Up Economy as its core strategic component).
One SME village would economically engage about 7000 persons from without the proposed village. This model could easily be replicated in a matter of 5 to 10 years, as pointed out earlier.
G 20’s decision to promote the SMEs could not have come at the more opportune moment. Even President Obama’s emphasis indicates the importance of this method. Now we need to handle it in such a way that the maximum out put could be had in as less a time as possible.
One SME village could consist of 100 to 500 families. Now in Pakistan there are thousands of villages whom we can adopt and initiate economic activity over there.
We do have the option of building new model villages where livestock, poultry forms, garments and other businesses could be established. They can be given the market linkages for their products.
The element of risk is eliminated with ownership of the provider whose staff would oversee the whole activity in the proposed villages.
The government can also come forward as the partner through providing land and roads etc.
The ownership of business and homes etc will gradually be transferred through diminishing Mudarbah or Murabaha, further mitigating the element of risk.
We have entered into very interesting times and the response must be intelligent and effective. It further adds to the responsibility of the World Bank, CGAP IDB and other financial institutions.
As far Pakistan is concerned, we need to move quickly before the next harvesting season. Government alone can hardly deliver in this regard. The stability of Pakistan is very important for the rest of the region, because the destabilized Pakistan next to Afghanistan could be a nightmare for the rest of the world. |
|
|
The Methodologies and Products of Microfinance both need refinement |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
If a product could not provide the solution to the purchaser against the price, how long it can stay in the market? No doubt the products of microfinance were need based, however they could not fulfill the actual objective of poverty alleviation as per the expectation. Although the cash based products fulfill the immediate need of the clients, but they cannot find the real solution to poverty. It goes against the vision and mission of the business. The productive loans proved unproductive at the end, that’s why crisis took place and the bubble market was created.
Microfinance was never a routine business, like an electronic or home appliance trade. It, of course, addressed a global curse of poverty. But Poverty is not a single dimensional phenomenon and irony was those trying to address it had no direct exposure to it. The people who made policies, most of them lacked a multi-dimensional approach to it. Off course, they conducted a lot of researches, invented various instruments and tools, however, all these efforts were intended to measure the poverty, without feeling it. There is a major difference between gauging and feeling it. There was another dilemma of the experts that they were studying the poor but were thinking that they are studying poverty.
It is strange to me, the people are still counting the heads of the vulnerable, and however they are not feeling the intensity of the starvation. I will recommend another rectal scale, which can measure the hunger and thirst, and behind. If we want to sell the solution of poverty, we have not only to know the poverty but have to feel the poverty, if we could. Otherwise we will again design the products similar to the ones that did not deliver. The previous products worked like a painkiller but not like a wound heeler. We launched the gigantic discussions on the various topics like "interest rates" or "whether microfinance is a social business or commercial". However we never try to analyze the nature of poverty to design the products accordingly. Even we did not try to know that which products built the assets for the poor in the human history within different cultures and geographies.
There is also a significant aspect that needs to be kept in mind that different people react differently in different times and spaces. Certainly different poor communities deal differently with their poverty in different situations. The people of Afghanistan are very different from the poor in India and the poor in Africa must be dissimilar than those in Indonesia. Nature of poverty in a far deep rural area is certainly different than that of a cosmopolitan city. Sometimes poverty forces to kill others, and sometimes pushes to commit suicide.
This is the time to find out of the box solutions in the real sense and not only as a fashion. The people who have a true concern with microfinance are seriously worried for the survival of the sector. My humble suggestion for them is to initiate an original product development move. Those who are focusing on the need for innovative products, they should be careful about the selection of the product developers. Sometimes products look original apparently but actually are not. It is a very critical time for the Global Economy. The microfinance is going to play a very significant role to strengthen the capitalism and free market economy as well. The new structures and partnerships are going to emerge out of reinventing microfinance. So the components like financial and non financial services, Social Performance Management and Information Systems must be intelligent and according to the nature of poverty. Methodologies and strategies also need refinement, and we have to design the products which can provide the solution against the price, the poor borrowers are paying. The long term profitability of the sector certainly depends upon this fact. Because if a soft drink cannot fulfill the thirst and does not satisfy the customer, It means it will be no more in the market. |
|
|
Reinventing microfinance in Pakistan |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
Poverty certainly emerged as the single most problem that lies at the heart of modern day crisis. It quite recently has assumed alarming proportions. Many efforts were made in the past but they could not wholly succeed. Among significant tools, the microfinance was also used for getting rid of poverty which quite recently plagued the whole world. There is always a room for innovation to be introduced to already existing structures. Though microfinance made some gains in alleviating it but with sufficient services the amount invested lie in the danger of being spent on the items of daily use owing to extreme poverty.
What in fact is required is the provision of certain services that may enable the person concerned to become self-earning unit. So the first and foremost thing in this regard is not to simply extend credit. It is more advisable to do kind of asset sharing, along with provision of services which could lead to an economic activity at an individual level.
Certain experiences in this regard bore good results. For instances a woman who was provided with the necessary material and skill, is successfully running her business of making and selling artificial flowers. What worked in this case was the fact the instead of extending credit, she was provided the raw material along with the skill. What could further be added to it is the provision of health and education facilities to the community so that each individual keeps on learning during this process.
By adopting this method microfinance becomes a well-organized business as well as a community services and incidence of default is reduced to the maximum level.
Now this issue of poverty is what upon which the future of political structures rests. It needs more coordinated and scientific approach. Among the efforts made so far, this method of empowerment through education and asset based loaning has bore good results. At a time when world economies are shrinking and people at large losing their jobs worldwide, this method could be used to off set the impact of recession in the poorer world. We have seen that the government agencies could not come up to the expectations and number of people falling below the poverty line is growing. The supply side economics or trickle down theory is being looked at with suspicion. We need more non-governmental structures to fight this growing menace.
Owing to shrinking world economy, the poor countries are also being hit hard. The individuals’ economies cannot sort this problem out as they have to cut their non-development expenses. In such a critical period poverty needs to be fought at war footing.
Recently, Farz Foundation (The First Islamic Microfinance Organisation ) has completed its two-year pilot project in the area of Shalimar Lahore in two phases. The organisation has done the comparative analysis of currency disbursement and the Farz Methodology (asset delivery method) in which the asset based microfinance shows 80 percent positive and productive results while the popular practice of microfinance, which is based on credit in the shape of currency depicted 80 percent negative and non-productive results. The study confirms the reports are already being published in the international journals about the very low impact of currency deals in microfinance. Although the efforts made by the CGAP and other agencies at the international level and Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund at the national level cannot be ignored but the speed of the inflation and poverty increase ratio demands more sincerer and creative efforts.
There is another challenge of exploring the new markets which still needs to be addressed because the process of demand and supply matters even at the level of the micro entrepreneurship. Home Based Women Entrepreneurs are still in the clutches of the middle man, who is earning far more than the HBMEs.
Another important issue is trust-building. The development sector has successfully won the hearts of the community but unfortunately the microfinance sector is losing the trust day by day particularly in Pakistan and India. Although The SEWA in India and RSPs in Pakistan has set the milestones remarkably, however, various MFIs have annoyed the poor community.
Though the poverty alleviation objective stipulates to support the innovative mechanisms like Farz Methodology, even at the government level as well as at the institutional level; the microfinance donors are not encouraging the new and innovative players as per the need and the requirement of the day. It will be lethal not only for the innovative human recourse of the sector but also will reduce the impact of the endeavors already being made by the sector of microfinance.
There is Chinese proverb that says we are living in very interesting times. Indeed we are. Old economic patterns are directly flying in our face. The ongoing recession has defied most of our beliefs. What triggered this, to put it brief, was the irresponsible ways of lending that almost sunk the world economy.
Amid all this there is another effort through lending to alleviate poverty, known as microfinance. It began with a justified fanfare and made certain gains as well but the over all outcomes betrayed some imperfections. This right up would tend to elaborate the so-called Farz Methodology, which, in fact, is another attempt to avoid certain negative outcomes. The irresponsible ways of lending, which we mentioned earlier and which almost sunk the ship of world economy, may also be one of the factors responsible for certain negative results in the world of microfinance.
What could not work in the cold world of business could never have done better where the borrower is a marginalized poor. Here comes the Farz Methodology which enshrines in its philosophy the passage to the relative well being of the person concerned through social as we as economic empowerment.
Another technique that this methodology carries is that of not allowing the direct access to the poor and the vulnerable to the hard cash. What is suggested instead is educating the poor along with providing him with necessary tools such as the stuff he needs to initiate an economic activity.
Our initial experience was also a clear testimony to the potential that this method carries. Our success rate in our projects remained 80 per cent which also worked as a spur because we had a long list of volunteers who were ready to work without compensation in the beginning
What made a clear difference was the realization that microfinance is not a mere business. It rather needs a business like skill, understanding of the world in which the poor exist and understanding of their limitations. We achieved this by looking at the world through the eyes of the poor.
Farz Methodology as an innovative economic mechanism ensures the long-term profitability of microfinance. We need to help the borrower make his business successful. Recovery, of course, cannot be had from a failed business. MFIs must make certain the recoveries from their profits, instead of their losses. Recovering from losses defeat the very purpose of the whole exercise. The micro trade cycle technique of Farz can ensure not only the sustainability of the sector but the long term profitability as well.
There are many researches that demonstrate that funds spent and efforts made are being wasted. What our methodology ensures is the maximum possible empowerment through basic health and education. Because the human resource of external organization (Members or clients ) should also be capable of delivering things well regarding their businesses. A business can not be a successful with bad health, illiteracy and skills. As the organizations build the capacity of their staff to get more and more output. Similarly microfinance sector will have to trained their clients to get more and more out put. So the integrated approach of Farz Foundation emphasizes on a skilled poor community to win the war against poverty to achieve the ultimate vision of the sector.
Today even the first world is no more unscathed by this recession. But that still has the advantage of a skilled labor. This fact alone would soon retrieve the falling economy in the rich countries, may be sooner than later. But in countries like Pakistan we need to initiate this activity on war footing.
The strategies of Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund (PPAF), studies of Pakistan Microfinance Network, (PMN) efforts of Social Performance Management and Social Performance Task Force focus on making loans productive through social performance is need of the hour.
Considering our collective past experience, we should not hesitate far a moment to implement these strategies with collaboration of Farz Methodology because the purpose of the sections is the same, how ever the Farz methodology will protect the expected gains. This would even help retrieve even the failing projects.
The capacity building of clients like training in credit discipline, basic marketing skill, and feasibility preparation are of paramount importance. This should be carried out the way we train our staff.
Another advantage of this strategy is that it would bridge conventional microfinance and Islamic banking. That would also allow us in a huge market that still remains untapped.
At a time when Pakistan’s economy is expected to grow by less than 2 per cent, we should adopt this measure to enhance the growth. Government is facing many other challenges like war on terror and perhaps cannot focus on economy as much as the civil society can. In the ultimate analysis war on terror could only be won through economic and social empowerment of the people. So the success of microfinance is the success of the forces struggling for peace and betterment of the country.
The idea of decoupling that was being put forth in the beginning of this recession could only be materialized by kick starting growth where the impact of the world recession is slightly less.
The task of course is gigantic. But of course the journey of thousands miles begins with one step. Let’s start restructuring existing MFIs methodologies and also begin establishing new projects to steer out of these testing times.
Changing the economic environment always calls for more innovative response. We, of course, are living in a time where hosts of events have crowded a comparatively short time span, particularly in the world of finance. Despite an incorporated world economy, the tools and methods needed in the so-called Third World would definitely be different from those of implied in the developed world. For instances the ways to fight poverty in the countries like Pakistan needs certain changes to suit a constantly aggravating economic situation.
The main emphasis in this approach is that by empowering an individual through services other than finance, in fact, we secure the money lent and make it productive over a long time. The most important task that today we face is not only to mitigate the impact of the recession but also to off set it. The governments in the region are tied with the host of other challenges, including war on terror. It makes it more important for the civil society to play its role in more effective and intelligent way. By kick starting an economic activity through incorporating the poor with provision of non-financial services as well as financial, we would bring them closer to the institution of microfinance. They own this whole process which in turn is enhancing their productivity and also inculcates a sense of responsibility among them.
The various research and evaluation projects have already unveiled the causes of the breakdown of the financial services system. So it is imperative to sort out a method which could offer a viable solution to provide a long-term relief. Undoubtedly the microfinance can provide a contingency plan in the right direction. Different studies suggest that the week impact of different microfinance methodologies already in place demand an innovative microfinance mechanism to be implemented at a large scale. The efforts made to link microfinance with Small Medium Enterprise (SME) and SME to Medium Enterprise and then macro enterprise are still in the process of achieving the goals to make any breakthrough. One reason behind not achieving our goals has been undue compartmentalization and division of work. What is needed, instead, is the integration. No business or credit or any financial system can be sustained in isolation. This is the core philosophy of Farz Microfinance Methodology. What goes without saying is the fact that consumption is the key to all types of production. Dwindling consumption means a stalled or hampered productive process. Thriving need-based local markets can become a gateway to micro productivity. At the micro enterprise level there are a lot of things that need to be addressed like the role of middle man and the whole sellers. Farz methodology emphasizes providing a just economic system for the productive poor according to their needs and requirements. The productive poor will have to be facilitated as a wheel for the international trade cycle. The role of currency should also be minimized and would have to be replaced by income generating kinds like tools and assets, etc. The artificial expansion of businesses or trade should be checked through asset providing mechanism. Farz Methodology as Noe Microfinance has proved through positive outcome as the most effective system in the given economic milieu. This inference has been made on the basis of results achieved in the poor neighborhoods like, Chongee Amarsidhu and Meu Colony in Lahore. Previously about eight MFIs targeted this area and six left by declaring them red (negative) areas. Two reaming are grappling with their zero tolerance policy and late night recovery problems. In the same area Farz Foundation has started its pilot to gauge the results and to observe the effectiveness of Farz Methodology.
First time in Pakistan the microfinance is being customized according to cultural and religious circumstances simultaneously unlikely the various previous practices. Farz Foundation has also launched a saving scheme that requires each member to pool a specific amount on monthly basis which is given to one member or the other on the basis of lucky draw. This is a practice known as committee (community's rotating funds) which develops saving habits and also works as a trust-building measure. What FF did was that it began, in accordance with Farz Methodology by conducting free eye camps and also picked some of the poor families and took the responsibility of paying for their children's education. Through further penetration into the area it was learnt that previously the borrowers were further lending the money at even a higher rate of interest, which defeated the very purpose of the whole exercise. They, of course, were bound to fail. All that Farz Foundation has dealt with so far does not lay bare the whole panorama of opportunities. In the future FF intends to provide direct market linkages to eliminate the role of middleman that will further increase the rate of profit of the home-based women entrepreneurs.
|
|
|
Rejoinder to Ruth David’s piece on Microfinance |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
Like any other sector microfinance is also going through difficult times. Ruth David in one of her articles ‘Worrying Signs in India’s Microfinance Boom’ published in Business week reveals, on 17th of June 2010.
“Microfinance markets in Nicaragua, Morocco, and Pakistan have seen default levels climb to more than 10 percent, the threshold that marks a "serious repayment crisis," according to a February report from policy and research firm Consultative Group to Assist the Poor”.
This, of course, coincides with the subprime loan crisis which has necessitated bail outs amounting to billions of dollars all over the developed world. Naturally, the strategists look for new methods and strategies to fight this economic malaise to protect all that is still good
in this world of economic and financial systems.
I, however, intend to look into what can be done to avoid a full blown crisis in this sector in this piece. What has been demonstrated after the arrival of this crisis was a kind of disconnect between the lenders and borrowers. This disconnect, in particular, can have devastating impact in the microfinance sector where the recipients are far more backward and poverty-stricken.
Having thoroughly looked at the crisis in the microfinance sector as mentioned above in the quotation, it was concluded that the idea of simply handing over the money to the needy expecting them to be productive by themselves didn’t work. Then we (The Farz Foundation) decided to provide productive assets on partnership basis to the clients, instead of cash. This however, was the first step. Leaving alone the client even at that level could be as hazardous as the subprime loan turned out to be. This facility was coupled with the business training and market linkages. This served a double purpose. On the one hand the foundation kept an eye on borrowers business activities along with providing support to make his or her business activity sustainable to the possible extent. All that borrowers have to pay for all this assistance was only 24 per cent as profit on sold asset. It, of course, is more than pertinent to mention that the usual practice has been to charge up to 120 per cent.
The Farz Foundation, along with all this, also began providing health facilities by conducting health camps. Much to our amazement, the provision of eye glasses transformed the lives of clients, who in the poor neighborhoods of Pakistan were even deprived of this basic facility.
The underlying aim behind all these activities was to create a relationship of trust with the clients that tremendously inspired them. They felt being a part of the whole exercise. The outcome in this age of rampant default was 98 per cent recovery. The two percent default owed itself to the death of some clients whose loans were written-off. To manage this risk in the future the Pak-Qatar Family Takaful Company was convinced to step in which insured our clients. This partnership with Takaful Company was first of its kind to be introduced in this sector of Islamic microfinance.
This whole experience was thoroughly dealt in my three earlier pieces namely, Reinventing Microfinance In Pakistan, which can be read at Microfinance Gateway( http://www.microfinancegateway.org and Microfinance Focus.
As pointed out earlier, new challenges require innovative response. we also introduced a traditional method of saving, locally known as committee. This method offers a unique opportunity to the participants to save a certain amount together with regular intervals. That amount is handed over to one of the participants after a lucky draw. The client is also offered to invest that amount with the Farz Foundation for further benefits as an other source of income.
Another interesting aspect of this method( Farz Methodology ) is that the client sees his or her survival and sustainability along with the sustainability of the microfinance provider.
According to an estimate, there are 2.5 billion people who still are unbanked in the world. WE still do have a huge market to be tapped. This may go a long way to off set the crisis triggered by all pervasive poverty on this globe. During these testing times, we must rethink our strategies and avoid the mistakes of the past. A stubborn adherence to the old modes may further complicate the things, endangering even the achievements of the sector. We need to preserve all that was good in the past experience while getting rid of the dead wood to reinvent the sector. Despite setbacks, all definitely has not been lost.
|
|
|
|
Farz Methodology: Making it big through scarce means |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
Achieving financial goals in such trying times is no mean business. Farz Foundation took up the task of fighting poverty when the microfinance world was giving in to one of the most unique and deep sustainability crisis. Much to our amazement, the initial outcome was quite encouraging.
Quite interestingly the whole operation was initiated with a small amount of Rs 2.5 million raised by the staff itself. Another NGO Akhuwat contributed Rs 0 .3 million. Out of this amount about Rs 0.7 million was disbursed among its 63 clients. Total number of beneficiaries’ amount to 409 persons who were provided healthcare and education. This step was aimed at restoring the confidence of people on the microfinance sector.
So far, the foundation has two offices including one central and one branch office. The staff in the branch office consists of 3 persons, one branch manager, an accountant and one field officer. The central office the staff of eight which consists of a CEO, GM operations, Manager Monitoring, Finance Officer, Manager Entrepreneur, Social performance Manager and a office boy.
The process was accompanied by the research operations, development of a unique methodology constant assessment of the success rate, development of SOPs, setting up of the internal control system, monitoring and evaluation, expansion plans and social performance management.
What needs a special focus in all this process was the fact that simultaneously a partnership was developed with Pak Qatar Family Takaful Pakistan for Islamic insurance, achieved first time in Pakistan. Another partnership developed with The Akhuwat to promote Islamic Microfinance operations.
Out of the whole invested amount of Rs 735,000, the receivable stands at Rs 892,820, recovered amount at Rs 152, 300, outstanding balance at Rs 722, 520 while Rs 18,000 was written off owing to the death of the client. Now, after the agreement with the Pak Qatar, such a risk has been taken care of once and for all. The recoveries are 99 percent on time with zero percent PAR.
So far 7 training sessions were conducted that include a workshop on Islamic Banking and Finance, Islamic products, principals of Murabaha, time management, client appraisal techniques, Farz Methodology, leadership and team building and translating social into mission. The clients training sessions were conducted separately on health awareness and business education.
There was another traditional method of saving, locally known as committees, was introduced to knit the clients with each other as well as with the foundation. This kind of method helps build the assets of the clients.
This already existing system of saving was made secure by formalizing it through incorporating it with the other Fraz Foundation operations. So far, 115 community members are participating in the process. This product is attracting increasing number of members with each passing day.
The first challenge that the foundation faced was the demand of clients for hard cash instead of assets. Knowing pretty well that the cash extended is mostly spent on immediate needs instead of initiating a productive activity, they were taught to understand how they can rid themselves of bad loans through using the assets provided by the foundation. They even were never shy of telling their intentions of using the cash on their immediate needs.
There were only two clients who mismanaged their business. We event didn’t gave up on that and gave them out of the routine training.
One important internal challenge was changing the mindset of the internal staff to adopt to the principals of Islamic Microfinance. That was taken care of through intensive training sessions. It is pertinent to mention that most of the staff so far works on voluntary basis.
But the greatest challenge that we face is the direly needed finance to tap a huge market that desperately awaits support. |
|
Need of the day: bridging development and microfinance |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
Results are always the best yardstick to measure the affectivity of any endeavor. It is not a matter of blame game or trading charges. To fight poverty all over the world requires stock taking of all the efforts made so far.
Let’s take the example of Pakistan and Afghanistan. Pakistan, of course, differs from Afghanistan as the microfinance sector at least took off but, much to our chagrin could not bear the expected results. Afghanistan still desperately looks for even the initial stage. In Pakistan the performance of the sector betrays a kind of rift of vision and mission. The facilitators at local level also failed to recheck the strategy in cases of utter failures and continued reckless financing. In doing so, the real players at local level were automatically ignored. Then, consciously or unconsciously, undesired results of the microfinance sector were attributed to the world economic crisis. The fact is that at least so far countries like India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and China maintained healthy growth rates despite the economic downturn in the first world.
No doubt, there were problems like inflation but failures cannot be attributed to a single factor. A business-like relation was required between the local facilitators and Partner Organizations (Pos) instead of personal one. It created a kind of complacency on the part of POs while the sector began to suffer. The registrations of more than 1,000 police cases also indicate the violation of Customer Code of Conduct. Then there occurred a crisis of confidence between the senior management of POs and there staff. In certain instances the management began to demand security checkups from their staff.
This breach of confidence also disillusioned the customers and cast doubt upon the sincerity of purpose, with which initially the whole exercise of the sector was launched.
Though Islamic finance has offered a viable and effective method, even this direly requires a sincerity of purpose.
Islamic finance, if taken up as a methodology could help tap a huge market which desperately needs a response from the sector.
The aspect of Amal-e-Khair (Social Performance) could off set the crisis of confidence between the POs and customers while hugely contributing to the success of the sector. Farz Methodology made healthcare, environment and education its components to ensure the sustainability of the sector, which cannot be had without the sustainability of the customer.
By bridging the development and microfinance sectors, we can successfully realize the goal of poverty alleviation. The countries like Afghanistan and Haiti also require this kind of combination. Poverty alleviation and development should simultaneously take place to isolate the elements who thrive on poverty, destruction and lack of education in countries Pakistan and Afghanistan.
The prime goal of the Farz Methodology is rapid and peaceful social and economic change. This goal requires integrated approach with a four bottom line Social Performance package.
Poverty is at the heart of all the ills and problems. I have personally seen the cases where poverty has pushed the individuals to an unthinkable extreme. After a lot of work with the sector, this methodology was formulated. A tremendous initial response gave a great deal of encouragement convincing us that through determination, sincerity of purpose and means, we can make a difference. |
|
Revitalizing Microfinance |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
The greatest dilemma of the twenty first century is translation of growth rates into the welfare of common man. For example India is considered to be a healthier economy even during this one of the deepest recession in history. India is growing by 8% to 9% and still its 77% population earn rupees 16 a day. 40% of India’s land is under the control of so called Maoists. Poverty is cited to be the reason behind this state of affairs. One laudable effort has been the role of microfinance, but even this effort could not equal the magnitude of this problem. This was also our dilemma, when we began our effort from the plat form of Farz Foundation. After having thorough analysis of this situation and after taking the stock of efforts made by the microfinance sector, I came to the conclusion that we need to reinvent our tools for fighting poverty as now, it is remain un checked, can threaten the whole system.
Interest has been an effective tool for development, and may remain so even in the future as well, as for as the major economic activity is concern. We reluctantly began our exercise of providing interest free and asset based microfinance along with provision of health and education facility and business training. The outcome was unbelievable.
According to the finance ministry of Pakistan, 3 out of 4 persons live on less than two Dollars a day. Microfinance sector so far has helped just 1. 8 Million People. Even that exercise had some set backs owing to the miss management of some players in the sector. Quite recently Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund has issued a letter to its partner organizations, directing them to inform PPAF about their other donors and also intimate them if they open a new branch. This fact alone indicates the set backs in the sector. CGAP also termed in one of its study the rapid growth of the sector was responsible for failures. It goes without saying that PPAF should have taken this step a little bit earlier. This letter also lays bare the fact that the local partners were approaching multiple donors for the same segment. Dwelling to much on the past may not look very pertinent. How ever it is very important to keep in mind the past practices to avoid a deep crisis of the sector, which seems quite possible in the near future. It also seems plausible that even KIVA,s interest free life changing loans were misused.
The core principle of Farz Methodology is the strong belief in transparency and information exchange. The dual audit by Sharia and conventional methods works as an double internal check in Farz Methodology. Farz Methodology mitigates the risk of fraud at field staff level, as it do not charge any thing as initial fee or documentation charges e.t.c.
On the larger scale the Farz Foundation intents to launch entrepreneurial villages in remote areas, housing live stock , home based business. Farz Foundation and Global Pakistan are going to sign an accord for solar solutions to fight energy crisis particularly in the far flung areas.
There is a potential market of at least 30 Million clients, which can be taped through MURABAHA, MUDHARBA and MUSHARKA products of microfinance. Launching of these products through Farz Methodology insures their exemptible as well as reduces the risk of default to a possible extant. The Farz Foundation intents to bring in a flesh blood to the sector through its innovative products. It is quite obvious, governments alone in the given situation can not fight poverty. An honest effort on the part of the sector through committed players can help achieve. |
|
|
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
We all know a success has many fathers and failure remains orphan. Crisis does come, and when they come, the best strategy always is to identify the factors contributing to it so that the past mistakes are not repeated, and the best remedies could be offered.
While not denying the contributions made by microfinance, we must begin stocktaking and re-evaluating our methods so that the best possible results could be had, in a not very distant future.
The Fraz Methodology, which has been extensively explained in this paper before, is a method which has practically knitted together different communities, while creating their relationship of trust with the primary lender. It goes without saying that Fraz Foundation, (FF) has a couple of people on its board and in management belonging to different minorities and first-ever branch of the foundation was opened in the area where mostly non-Muslims live and they are among the beneficiaries.
One good thing about Islamic finance is that it offers partnership without any regard to caste, colour and creed. And the minorities at their end never mind being helped by whosoever takes up this noble job.
As explained in the earlier articles (Reinventing Microfinance in Pakistan), we learnt our lesson from the experience in microfinance loan repayment crisis. We found it far more imperative to adopt an asset-based methodology, instead of cashed-based strategy.
Another important fact regarding this crisis was that politicians only stepped in when it (crisis) had already brewed to an unsustainable level. The very fact that finally a couple of politicians at a local level in their individual capacity had to be involved indicates unrest among the borrowers. The senior politicians at both the federal and provincial level even came to the rescue of lenders.
CGAP’s (Consultative Group to Assist the Poor) assessment that the rapid growth in the field resulted in the crisis, is perhaps an undeniable fact. But, of course, there never is a single factor behind any crisis or failure.
First and the foremost factor was irresponsible lending practices, for instance, weak screening of clients and selection criteria which depended on the middleman (activist) instead of direct approach.
Secondly the treatment of the staff with borrowers raised many eyebrows. Another important factor was the primary lender’s attitude towards its own staff. This further led to a kind of distancing of the borrowers from the top management of the lending organizations.
Now there is a general realization that even the international economic crisis owes itself to the rapid growth and irresponsible lending practices.
Another negligence on the part of lenders was the absence of any data-based record of borrowers which now is admitted on all hands. Now realizing it is perhaps a bit too late as crisis has already been caused.
Pakistan Microfinance Network and Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund have already taken up this vital task which in future would help secure the sector.
A key to every success in any kind of community-related work requires building a relationship of trust, while observing strictly certain principles. Anton Simanowitz, Director Social Performance Network, once said that microfinance practitioner must have a mind of banker and a heart of a social worker.
A cursory glance over the plight of minorities in Pakistan indicates nothing substantial. For instance, a minority area in Lahore known as Yuhana Abad has been declared a red zone by organizations that claim to have worked in this community.
No one can deny we are passing through very difficult times. What is needed is to join hands for not repeating the mistakes of the past. It is not the question of any individual success or credibility. Fraz Foundation and its methodology have embarked upon the tasks of proving the usefulness of microfinance sector in fighting the curse of poverty.
To be brief, Fraz methodology emphasizes such products which are market-driven, and are according to the borrowers’ needs. As stressed earlier, microfinance borrower is not a consumer in the traditional sense of the word. He is an already handicapped individual who needs finance and also help in the form of capacity-building to make that financing an income-generating process.
Through its experience the FF has proved the usefulness of its method by working in sectors already abandoned by other lenders. We have, in short, turned these red zones into green ones. Sooner than later, Farz Foundation will demonstrate its work in Yuhanna Abad through Farz Methodology. The poor, of course, want to change their lives. All that we need is to initiate the process with commitment, honesty, and a flawless method. |
|
New partnerships to enhance outreach, poverty reduction, and social performance in microfinance |
By Farhat Abbas Shah |
Despite colossal efforts, the poverty has emerged as the single most problem in the contemporary world. Microfinance has been one of the major tools to fight it, but it still needs restructuring, particularly, in the wake of the worst recessions in the history of prevalent economic structures. This situation also requires us once again to look at all the efforts done thus far and to achieve the noble goal of reducing poverty to the possible extent.
Before dwelling on what is needed to be done to fight poverty, one must analyze the methods applied hitherto in this field. What goes without saying is that despite all the good intentions, the sought after results could not be had through microfinance. One needs to look at the sub prime loan crisis in the most developed economies to understand this dilemma even in the underdeveloped world. Simply lending money without understanding the milieu in which an individual is placed has kept us away from the desired goals.
The person who was lent money through microfinance was and is far more handicapped than those of the developed world. If the method that was adopted to extend credit in the advanced world couldn’t work, how could it bear results where the subject was far more vulnerable? So what happened was quite natural. The extended cash was mostly misused because of the subjects’ most urgent needs which resulted in the late night recoveries and the registration of cases in the police stations against the delinquent borrowers in the countries like Pakistan. Naturally, one could not retrieve money from somebody’s expenditures or losses.
Having gone through this experience, a new concept known as Farz Methodology was adopted, which simultaneously aims at social performance through the provision of necessary education, health facilities and finally the provision of income generating and productive assets (MURABAHA), instead of extending cash. The repayment was further made easy as it comes out of the profit instead of interests. Interest may work pretty well in other instances, but here we need to give the sense of participation as well through the social performance as a trust -building tool. Recovery in this way is even more than 99 percent. Secondly it also helped the individuals through their economic uplift.
What made a real difference was that through the process of social performance, considering the borrowers as external staff of the organization, a general assessment of the person was also ascertained regarding his capability to become a productive member of the Farz Foundation. Secondly, the recovery is made through very easy installments. For instance, one person who was given a cart, is making Rs 700 per day, and he only pays back Rs 700 twice a month which is not at all a bad bargain for him. This is only one incidence out of many.
Another important factor was the transparency with which the whole exercise was launched. It also gave the confidence and wish to the borrowers to stay forever with the organization, because a kind of cold relationship with the borrower cannot inspire him and a lack of guidance results in the wastage of the amount extended. Resultantly an inspiration engendered a hope and a wish to come out of the misery of poverty.
Another thing that served as a lag was the peculiar conditions that exist in the third world. Usually any activity to alleviate poverty was taken with a certain amount of suspicion from the borrowers. The workshops and training sessions held with the borrowers gave them confidence through the Farz Methodology. Another confidence building measure was the health camps for Home Based Micro Entrepreneurs. Those with eyesight impairment were provided, for instances, with glasses to see well. This may look like a small step but by removing their impairment, we witnessed a huge change in the borrower’s attitude towards microfinance.
To inculcate a sense of harmony, a traditional system of saving, known as the committee, was also introduced through which each member contributes to a common fund which is given to one member each time with a draw. It not only knits them into one community, but it also helps them save money.
It is quite obvious that the whole world of finance is going through one of the most critical periods in history. In the recent scenario, it has become far more imperative to fight the menace of poverty. Hard times always require innovative and creative solutions, and definitely new partnerships with ground breaking mechanism.
At the macro and micro both levels, the times demand joint and concerted efforts on the part of various world institutions. In other words, need of the hour is to bridge traditional as well as modern methods to create a possibly balanced financial world. To put it more concretely, Islamic and modern finance should be brought together. The best of both experiences should keenly be analyzed and incorporated to have greater success in this very vital field. What goes without saying is the fact that we are fast running out of time. All the means available should be put together. The methodology recommended here could hugely contribute towards the goal of poverty alleviation through the integrated approach of Farz Methodology. The future of all the liberties achieved through the market economy hinge upon the fact how successfully we tackle this issue.
It is being claimed by the critics of the prevalent economic structures that world of finance in general is in uncharted waters. This may partially be true but as far as poverty is concerned it could only be drastically reduced through the kind of participation and togetherness that Farz Methodology offers. Farz Methodology also suggests a partnership between microfinance industry and development sector. This partnership can work miraculous in achieving an ever illusive poverty free world. |
New partnerships are inevitable to begin a new era of global economy. Hence there is a question of continuity of previous partners which could not achieve the mutually agreed targets. Dominique Lesaffre a microfinance thinker and intellectual from France says, responding to my previous article under the same name as part1,at MFP dated,5 April 2010.
“ I personally believe poverty is the major outcome of (economical if
not political) injustice, not only a matter of lack of access to
(financial) services. For example, in my own country, a supposedly
'rich' one, France, a recent survey has shown that nearly 22% of the
population has gone through poverty over the last 7 years. 22%!! In
the meantime, the same investigation by “Le Monde” mentions that the
richer ones have never been as rich as now and the 'crisis' actually
did not affect them. I mention that as "microfinance for the poor" is
no longer a mere instrument of "poverty alleviation tool for
developing countries", it has become, by default, one of the global
answers to compensate the effects of structural injustice. Even in
France, microcredit has come high in the public agendas as a policy
and instrument for 'poverty alleviation', meaning that the welfare
state is no longer able to bring about the requested social
compensations. The point here is not to judge whether good or not, but
to take act of it.”
I may disagree with “Le Monde” point of view. However, we will have to accept that the microfinance instrument could not provide the expected results during last two or three decades. If I see the players working in Pakistan, there cannot find any healthy partnerships, particularly at bottom level. MFIs never ever even think that the poor can be their partners at any level. As for as top level partnerships are concerned, there is again a first come first get policy seems to be flying in our faces. In Pakistan MFPs seems to be compelled for working with even constant insustained institutions for un known reasons. They even neither try to build the trust between each other nor to fulfil the responsibility to meet the objective of poverty alleviation by there hearts. Monitoring and evaluation claims and exercises have failed. Partnerships perhaps remained confined to mere paper work.
I have still a strong belief about microfinance as an effective instrument to alleviate poverty, but not just micro credit and without Social Performance. According to my observation, the people sitting in the institutions made their efforts not with required commitment and enthusiasm required by the donors and investors which agreed to spend a handsome part of their investments for Best Practices and capacity building as well.
It is an encouraging stride to find out the ways of new partnerships but we need to bring in new talent instead of only relying upon the old one.
At this turning point of the century, we have a chance to take a bold step. We also will have to take brave initiatives regarding new partnerships. At macro level the same old methodology may work well but on the micro level new initiatives are need of the hour to cope with fast changing economic climate. I am pretty sure the ultimate success depends on transforming the poor borrowers into a productive vehicle of partnership, so that they could emerge out of a desperate economic situation with a great sense of ownership, while ensuring the success of the sector at macro level. This object can only be achieved through creating a partnership with the poor borrower. As a grass root expert, I would like to recommend strongly to principally announce the poor as a partner of microfinance providers. This partnership can bring about a sea change for the international economy in the shape of long term profitability. Sam Daley Harris, Chairman of The Micro Credit Summit Campaign, can take the credit for this important realisation. President Bark Obama and his policy makers have also realized the importance of end users and the need for new partnerships as well. However, it is difficult to assess whether they have judged the need for partnership with the poor particularly with reference to the third world. As for as Pakistan is concerned, the present partner organizations could not even build the trust between the microfinance provider and borrower, while the government of Pakistan is very keen to facilitate the sector. The initiatives of the State Bank of Pakistan are also very encouraging. The strategic partnership with governments and business partnership with the poor is the combination which can enhance the outreach, reduce poverty and make the sector profitable for a long time. |
|
|
| |
| |
FarzFoundation.org © 2010 | All rights reserved |
| |
|